I have done this quite a few times but have never made a "keeper" image. I have never heated them or dipped them, just polished away the old image. It will take a bit more than red rouge to get the old image and tarnish off. The silver sulfide tarnish layer actually consumes/combines with the silver and leaves a very rough surface once it is removed the more tarnish the worse the surface, also old matt marks are often deep and very hard to get rid of. If you polish gently and are not too picky about the matt marks and irregular surface from the tarnish you can often make two or three attempts before you polish through to the copper, assuming the original user got it right on the first try. I have polished old ones multiple times thinking they were still good and then during gilding the thin silver allowed the copper to react with the gold and make orange stains all over the image. One other thing is that the old plates often have the edges bent back and you need to correct the focus to compensate for the plate not being flat. -Larry